I have to own up and confess that I have quite a collection of field guides. If I see one 2nd Hand that I don't have (in an Oxfam book shop, for instance) I usually buy it. most of them I wouldn't dream of taking out (too bulky, very out of date, misleading illustrations etc etc). I was brought up on Peterson, Mountfort and Hollom, and have grown to like the pointers to diagnostic features on the plates - but always found the separation of plate and text really frustrating, involving much page turning and swearing. At least the latest edition has all the plates in one section. I also use Collins "Most complete...." and the RSPB Pocket Birds, although the latter is all photographs which I don't like as much as paintings.
Face it though, no book is ever going to let you identify everything you see, there will always be the ones that get away.....
Chaz
|